The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 4 · 4. him

Chapter 4

4. him

5 min read

It is after midnight, and he is awake.

The town is still searching for the first one. He knows this the way he knows the weather, without needing to look. Flyers on every lamppost. Voices calling a name down every road. An entire town spread out in the dark, searching, and not one of them knows where to look.

He doesn't blame them. Nobody looks where they've never been taught to look.

The notebook lies in the drawer, locked. He takes it out and puts it on the desk, and doesn't open it straight away.

He has been thinking about how easy it was. Not easy to do. Easy to hide. Those are different things, and the second is the one that counts. Nobody is hunting for a quiet man with a kind face and steady hands. Nobody ever has been.

But he is no fool. Something that works once can fail the second time, and he has no wish to fail.

So he is careful.

He has kept a list for years. Not on paper. Paper can be found. The list lives in the part of him that never sleeps, a short column of names, each one rubbed smooth from handling.

In the notebook, he writes only initials.

image

He reads it back. It could pass for grief, or the diary of some very private sorrow.

Anyone who found it would understand nothing. That is the entire art of it: writing the truth in a language only he can read.

He shuts the notebook and sits for a while, listening to the house.

*

By Friday, she is gone.

He hears it the way everyone does, from the faint, bright buzz of a town starting to worry. A neighbour who hasn't seen her. A door that hasn't opened. A car on the drive with a thin film of dust on the windscreen.

On Saturday he walks past the house.

Not slowly. Slow is something people remember. He walks at his normal pace, with his normal face, and looks at the house the way anyone would, with a mild, passing sympathy.

The curtains are shut. A newspaper lies on the step, still in its plastic wrapper.

He waits for something to happen inside him.

Fear would make sense. Guilt would be human. He knows the shapes of both, the way a man who has never visited a city knows its streets from maps. He keeps still and checks for them, carefully, like probing a tooth.

Nothing.

There is only a calm, level attention. The feeling of watching a machine run for the first time and noting, with great interest, which parts move.

His shoulders ache. He blames the week. It has been a long one, and there is more work in something like this than anyone would guess.

He turns the corner and doesn't look back. Behind him, the newspaper lies on the step, and the town carries on searching all the wrong places, and a second name shifts, without fuss, from one column to the other.

*

A careful man would want to know if the mask still fits.

He doesn't trust himself to feel it. He has noticed, lately, how much of him is performance, and how little he can find beneath it. So he tests it, the way you test a floorboard before you put your weight on it.

Across the road, an old woman has been putting up notices for weeks. A cat missing from her porch, a faded photo taped to a post, the ink running in the rain. Everyone walks past and feels a small, polite pity. Nobody does a thing.

He walks the alleys behind the shops for two evenings. On the third, he finds it, skinny and filthy and furious, hiding under a stack of crates behind a bakery.

He carries it to her door wrapped in his coat.

The old woman cries. She presses the cat to her face and laughs and sobs and asks his name three times, and a neighbour leans out of a window and says, "Aren't you lovely."

He smiles. It is a perfect smile, the best he has ever produced. He accepts the thanks with exactly the right amount of modesty, and a pat on the arm, and a promise to drop by for tea.

He feels nothing whatsoever.

That is the result of the test, and he reads it without alarm. The mask holds. It holds better than he ever imagined. Whatever lives behind it has stopped needing to be seen.

They'll love him for this. They'll tell the story for weeks. And the next time something happens in this town, and the next, and the one after, they'll remember the kind man who found the cat, and it will never cross their minds to look at his hands.

*

He sits at the desk for a long time that night, the notebook open in front of him, the pen in his hand.

He has been so careful. Two names crossed off. A harmless good deed for a stranger's cat. He has moved quietly and in small steps, like a man standing at the edge of very deep water, scared to get his feet wet.

He is tired of being careful.

He thinks of the list, the long, patient column of it, the years he has carried it. He thinks of the people who sleep soundly. The people who moved on. The people who looked at him, once, and saw nothing worth noticing.

He thinks of how small it was, in the end. How little it took. A quiet night. A patient hand. A town that wanted to be kind and had no idea what to watch for.

And he thinks: if it was this easy, what else is possible?

The question opens in him slowly, like a door in a house he has lived in all his life and never once tried.

He thinks of the others. Everyone who has ever stood between him and what he wanted. Everyone who has ever been loved more easily than he was. He doesn't name them. He doesn't need to. They're already there, a long, glittering line of possibilities, waiting at the bottom of the page.

His hand has stopped. The pen hovers.

For weeks, he has been asking himself whether he could.

He looks at the blank page one last time.

Then he starts to write, and doesn't stop, and doesn't ask himself anything.

He is deciding.

*

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.