The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 5 · 5. Richard

Chapter 5

5. Richard

11 min read

Richard had been stuck on fourteen across for most of an hour when someone knocked at the door.

Six letters. To leave without opening. He had UNREAD and he hated it. It wouldn't sit with twenty two down, and twenty-two down was a perfectly decent word.

The knock came again, three raps, patient and polite. He knew that knock. He'd taught it.

He put the pen down, uncapped, which irritated him, and went to the door in his socks.

"Detective Okafor," he said. "It's barely seven."

"Richard." Dana stood on the porch with her hands in her coat pockets and her breath clouding in the cold. She was forty now, he realised, or close to it. It seemed impossible. He still remembered a twenty six year old who had been sick at her first scene and then walked straight back in. "Sorry. I should have rung."

"You should have. But you didn't, which means you're here about something you don't want on the phone." He stood aside. "Come in. I'll put the kettle on."

She sat at the kitchen table with her coat still on, her eyes moving round the room the way he'd trained her: exits,, windows, anything out of place. When they reached the corner of the front room, where the blanket lay over the old boxes, she looked away quickly and pretended she hadn't.

He pretended as well.

"Two people," she said, once the kettle began to whistle.. "Gordon Pryce, runs the tyre shop on Mill Road. Fifty-six, divorced, no kids. Left the shop Friday night and nobody's seen him since."

Richard went still with the teapot in his hand.

He hadn't meant to. It was a very small stillness, the kind nobody would register unless they knew him. But for half a heartbeat the kitchen seemed to tip, and the name landed in his chest like a stone dropped down a well.

Pryce.

"Richard?"

"Go on." He poured. His hand was perfectly steady. "You said two."

"Marianne Doyle. Forty-eight, lives alone on Larch Street. Her neighbour noticed the papers stacking up. Her car's on the drive, her handbag's still in the house. No sign of a struggle." Dana wrapped both hands round the cup he gave her. "Nine days since Pryce, four since Doyle. Nothing connects them. No history, no link, they barely knew each other. But the chief doesn't like it, and I don't like it, and the papers are starting to ask questions."

"What does the chief want?"

"He wants you." She said it carefully. "Not officially. A consultant's fee, a desk, access to the files. Fresh eyes from someone who's seen this sort of thing before. He thinks a pattern might be forming and he wants someone who'd know it when he saw it."

"A pattern."

"Two people in nine days, in a town this size." She held his gaze. "You always said that's how it starts."

He looked down at his tea. A skin was forming on top, thin and grey. He watched it for a moment.

"I'm retired," he said.

"I know."

"Eleven years."

"I know." She hesitated. "I wouldn't have asked if there was anyone else."

"Alright," Richard said.

It came out too quickly. He heard it, the way you hear a glass hit the floor half a second before you see it shatter.. He had meant to think about it. He'd meant to say let me sleep on it, to be reluctant, to be sensible.

Instead, he'd said yes before she'd even finished asking.

Dana looked faintly surprised. Then she nodded, relieved, and he got up to refill the kettle so he wouldn't have to see whatever was on his own face..

*

The station smelled exactly the same.

That was what struck him first, walking through the double doors at half nine with a visitor's badge clipped to his cardigan: floor polish, burnt coffee, toner, and beneath it all the old, faint, unmistakable smell of too many people living too hard in too small a space.. Eleven years, and nothing had changed.

They gave him a desk in the corner of the open-plan office, by a window that didn't open. Someone had left a mug on it. Someone else had stuck a note to the mug that said Welcome back! in handwriting he didn't know. He turned the mug upside down and moved it aside.

Dana brought the files in two boxes, a thin one and a thinner one.

"Pryce is the better of the two," she said. "We've got a witness."

"Walk me through it."

The witness was a man named Abernathy, seventy-one, a retired postman who walked his dog at eleven every night, whatever the weather. He'd been passing the tyre shop on Mill Road the night Pryce vanished and had seen a man by the side of the building, near the alley.

Richard read the statement twice. Then once more, slowly, pen in hand.

"A man, I'd say. Not tall, not short. Average. Dark jacket, navy maybe, maybe black. A cap, I think, pulled down. He wasn't rushing. That's what sticks with me most. Everyone rushes at that hour, in the cold. He just stood there like he had all the time in the world. Spike barked at him, which he never does at anyone, and then stopped, and I felt daft. The man glanced over, nodded, and went round the corner. I didn't think anything of it. I thought he worked there."

Below it, the officer who'd taken the statement had added a list of follow-up details, the sort of thing a witness drags up the second time round:

No bag or tools. Soft-soled shoes, silent on the gravel. Smelled of cold air and something sharp, maybe cleaning stuff. Seemed in a good mood, humming or similar. Wiped his hands on his sleeve like he'd been working. No gloves.

Richard worked down the list. He underlined humming, because that was odd, and soft-soled shoes, because that was careful, and a good mood, because that was the bit that made the back of his neck go cold.

He circled nothing else. The rest was the kind of detail every witness gives and every investigator sifts, and it all ran together. A man, average, dark jacket, calm.

"Not a lot," Dana said, watching him.

"It's enough to start with." He tapped the page. "He wasn't rushing. That's not a thief, and it's not someone who panicked. That's somebody who's finished thinking about it."

"Or somebody who works there and was locking up."

"Gordon locked up. Alone. For nine years." He shut the file. "Who else had keys?"

"His assistant. Lad called Cal Reyes. Pryce sacked him on Monday."

"Why?"

"Money. Cal owed him some, borrowed against his wages, never paid it back. Gordon told him to pack his things and go." Dana shrugged. "He's twenty-three. No alibi for Friday night. Says he was home playing video games, on his own."

"Everybody's home playing video games on their own," Richard said. "It's the disease of the age."

She nearly smiled. "There's one more thing. A man sleeps behind the shop sometimes. A drifter. A few of the lads know him as Eddie. We've asked patrol to bring him in."

Richard looked at the window, at the grey car park beyond it, at nothing much.

"Good," he said. "Let's start with the boy."

*

Cal Reyes was the sort of young man who had never been told no and was starting to suspect it was on its way.

He slumped in the interview chair, arms folded, chin tucked in, glaring at the table, a sulky, narrow-shouldered boy with a patchy beard and the bitten nails of someone who hadn't learned to sit with his own worry. He'd been in the room an hour already. He'd stopped being frightened and started being angry, which was a better sign, and a worse one.

"I told them," he said. "I told everyone. I didn't do anything."

"No one's saying you did," Richard said mildly.

"Everyone's saying it." Cal's eyes flicked up, wet and furious. "He sacked me. I know how it looks. I was angry. Yeah, I said things. I said I hoped his stupid shop burned down. I was angry."

"Where were you Friday night?"

"Home."

"Doing what?"

"Playing... I don't know. A game. I had my headset on. There's a log, there's a, it records when you're online." He swallowed. "I wasn't there. I'd never hurt him. He was a prat sometimes, but he gave me a job when nobody else would."

Richard watched him. He watched his hands, which were shaking. He watched his eyes, which couldn't stay still. He watched the set of his shoulders, the clench of his jaw, the way he kept angling his body toward the door..

A frightened boy. A guilty boy, maybe, of something. Not of this.

Nothing about him was calm. Nothing about him was patient. If Abernathy's man was a surgeon, Cal Reyes was a kid with a hammer.

"Thank you," Richard said. "That's all."

Dana caught him in the corridor.

"The chief likes him for it," she said. "Motive, no alibi, a temper."

"He's a child who shouted at his boss." Richard rubbed his eyes. "The man outside that shop wasn't angry. He was content. That's a very different thing."

"You think it's the same man for both?"

"I think I haven't seen enough yet."

Eddie was easier.

He sat at the table with his knees pressed together, a thin, weather-beaten man in layered coats with a carrier bag of belongings at his feet, and he looked at Richard with the open, wary gentleness of a stray that has been kicked often and stays, against all the evidence, hopeful.

"I didn't see nothing," he said, when asked. "I sleep behind the shop sometimes, like, when it's cold. Gordon didn't mind. He'd leave the door on the latch for me, the back one. He was a good man."

"Was it open on Friday?"

"No." Eddie frowned, thinking. "That was strange. The back light was off, too. It's always on. And the door was shut tight. I thought maybe he was cross with me." His eyes welled up. "I should've knocked. Maybe if I'd knocked."

"You didn't do anything wrong," Richard said, and meant it.

"Do you think he's alright?"

Richard looked at the thin face, the cracked hands, and found he couldn't tell this man a comforting lie. "I don't know," he said. "But I'm going to find out."

When he came out, Dana was waiting with a coffee. She held it out and he took it, though he didn't want it.

"Neither of them," he said.

"Neither of them fits."

"No." He stared into the paper cup. "Which means we're after someone the department hasn't thought of yet. Someone who doesn't look like what we're looking for."

"That's a very wide net."

"It always is." He drank the coffee. It was awful. "Find out what Marianne Doyle did for a living. Who she knew. Who she was frightened of. And Dana?"

"Yeah?"

"Don't let the chief arrest that boy until I say so."

*

By the time he got home it was dark, and the house was very quiet.

He didn't switch on the lamp. He sat at the kitchen table in his coat, hands flat on the wood, and let the silence settle.

Gordon Pryce.

Marianne Doyle.

He said the second name out loud, softly, to the empty room..

"Marianne Doyle."

Nothing happened. The fridge hummed. A pipe ticked somewhere in the wall. But something shifted inside him, slowly, deep and cold, like a shape rising beneath ice.

He knew the name.

He had known it since Dana said it that morning, the way you know the sound of your own front door.. He just wasn't going to know it yet. There was a part of him, old and practised and very tired, that had learned over many years how to step round certain things without ever quite admitting they were there. It was good at its job. It had never once let him down.

He stood. He crossed the front room in the dark, past the crossword with its stubborn UNREAD, past the mantelpiece with its photograph he never looked at, and stopped in front of the corner.

The blanket lay over the boxes exactly as it had since last week. Grey wool. A bit dusty.

He reached out and laid his hand flat on top of it.

Underneath, the cardboard was cool and slightly damp. The lid of the top box had a year written on it in black marker, faded, in his own handwriting. He didn't need to lift the cloth to see it. He knew exactly which year.

Thirty years of cases, the kids always said.. He can't throw anything out.

They weren't wrong. They just didn't know which of the thirty he couldn't throw out..

He stood there with his hand on the blanket for a long time. He thought of Dana's face in the kitchen. He thought of the chief's phone call, of how he'd said yes before he'd been asked. He thought of two names, and how neither of them, alone, meant anything at all.

He didn't lift the blanket.

At the front of the house, a key turned in the lock.

Richard snatched his hand away, as if the wool had burned him, and turned as the door swung open and the hall light spilled in.

"Hey." Julian stood on the threshold with a paper bag in one arm and the cold still clinging to his coat. "Thought you might not have eaten. I got soup from the place on Pine."

"I've eaten," Richard lied.

"No, you haven't." Julian smiled, came in, and kicked the door shut with his heel. He crossed the dark front room without glancing at the corner, the way he always did. Always went round it, as if the boxes were furniture, as if the blanket were just a blanket. A polite boy, Richard thought. A boy who knew which corners to leave alone.

The kitchen light clicked on. A pan clattered. Julian's voice drifted back, warm and unhurried. "Dana rang Theo. Said you're consulting? That's brilliant, Dad. About time you got out of the house."

Dad.

Richard took a breath, and walked into the light.

"Julian," he said.

"Yeah?"

He stood in the doorway and looked at the young man at the stove, the broad shoulders, the steady hands, the easy tilt of his head as he ladled soup into a bowl. He had watched this boy grow up. He knew the shape of him as well as he knew his own handwriting.

There was a question in his throat. He didn't know where it had come from. It sat there, small and cold and ridiculous.

"Do you ever think about—" he began.

Julian turned his head. "About what?"

The kitchen was warm. The soup smelled of garlic. "Crosswords," Richard said. "Fourteen across. Six letters. To leave without opening."

Julian considered it, spoon in hand, with the solemn attention of a boy doing someone a favour.

"Unread?"

"Doesn't fit."

"Then it'll come to you." He put the bowl on the table, pulled out a chair, and waited, smiling, until Richard sat down. "Eat. Please. You look shattered."

Richard looked at the soup. He picked up the spoon.

SEALED, he thought, and went very still.

Six letters.

He ate the soup.

*

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.