Chapter 6
6. Round Table
13 min read
The knock at her door came at half seven, and Annie knew without looking who it was.
No one else ever knocked. The building had a buzzer downstairs, and the few people who visited used it. Only Julian climbed all four flights and tapped twice, softly, like a man who didn't want to wake anyone who might already be asleep.
She opened the door.
He stood in the narrow corridor with a cardboard box in his arms, coat open, hair wet from the drizzle. Behind him, through the stairwell window, she could see his white work van at the kerb, the ladder rack beaded with rain.
"Hi," he said. "Sorry. I know it's late."
"It's not late."
"It's a bit late." He shifted the box. "Can I come in? It's heavier than it looks."
She stepped back, and he walked into her flat the way he always did, as if the place deserved care. He took in the kitchenette, the single chair, the window with its view of brick, and didn't let his eyes rest on any of it. He put the box on the counter.
"What is it?"
"Open it."
Inside, wrapped in newspaper, were four plates.
They were plain, white, heavy, with a thin blue line round the rim. The kind of plates that would survive a house full of children. She lifted one out and turned it over. A faded sticker on the base read Made in Portugal.
"They're not new," Julian said quickly. "I found them at a house clearance. I didn't think you'd want anything too fancy. I just... you had a set of four once. And two broke, and you never replaced them, and I kept thinking, I don't know. It seemed like a small thing someone ought to fix."
Annie held the plate to her chest.
She had told him exactly once. Years ago, offhand, laughing, standing in this kitchen with a broken one in her hand and a dustpan. Oh well. Only me anyway. She hadn't even remembered saying it. He had.
"Julian," she said. Her voice caught, and she hated it. "You didn't have to do this."
"I know."
"It's too much."
"It's four plates." He smiled, a little awkward. "It's a housewarming present. Seven years late."
She laughed, and her eyes stung, and she turned away to hide it, busying herself with the box, unwrapping the others one at a time, stacking them on the counter. Four plates. A set. Something that said company is expected.
When she looked up, Julian was standing very still in the middle of the room, looking at the mugs on the draining rack. Upside down, waiting patiently.
He said nothing about it. Something passed across his face, quick and quiet, and was gone.
"I should get going," he said. "Richard's waiting. He doesn't eat unless someone makes him."
"Stay. I'll make tea. I've got, um." She looked round. "Two mugs."
"Next time." He was already at the door, hand on the frame. "Use the plates, alright? Don't save them."
"I won't."
"Good."
He was about to leave when Annie stopped him.
“Jules, can I ask something?”
“Sure, anything.”
“How does one know when they’re in love?”
“That’s a big question and all of a sudden?”
“It’s just..you know…Theo.”
There was a bit of silence that lasted longer than a second. Julian smiled at her.
“He thinks about it as well.”
“He does?” she spoke in excitement.
Julian had never seen her eyes lit up so much before.
“At times. But yeah he does. You know you’re in love when your eyes smile and shine on the mention of their name and yours do every time it’s Theo.”
“So..am I in love?”
“Well it might be too soon to say but he’s not bad. He’s perfect, for you.”
Julian saw Annie’s eyes glitter when he said that. Looking at her smile like that, he thought, it’s because of Theo, it’s always him.
“I’ll take my leave now. And you? Don’t think much. I’ll get him to tell you everything sooner.”
He smiled once more, and was gone. She heard his boots on the stairs, quick, then the front door, then the van's engine starting in the rain. She stood at the window and watched the tail lights turn the corner.
She'd never actually thanked him. She'd meant to. She'd had the whole speech lined up.
She lifted one of the plates off the stack and placed it carefully on the shelf by itself, where she could see it from the bed.
*
The dining room at Richard's had turned into a command centre overnight.
A map of the town was taped across the wall, bristling with coloured pins. Sticky notes covered every surface: yellow for tips, pink for leads, green for crossed off. In the centre of the table sat an old landline Richard had dug out of a cupboard, because the police tip line was swamped and he said people trusted a number that rang in a real house.
"They trust a real house?" Theo had said. "That's the least trustworthy sentence I've ever heard."
"You're here, aren't you?"
"Under protest."
So there they were, on the third evening, a small scruffy volunteer army: Richard at the head of the table, silent and grey-faced, reading a thick folder with his glasses slipping down his nose; Theo cross-legged on the floor with a notepad; Julian at the map, adjusting pins; and Annie by the phone, holding a mug of tea and trying to look like someone who knew what she was doing.
The phone rang.
She answered. "Tip line."
"Is this the psychic hotline?"
Theo made a strangled sound from the floor.
"No, sir," Annie said, as evenly as she could manage. "This is for information about the missing people."
"I know. I've got information. I've been seeing it in my dreams. There's a tall man, and water, and something shaped like a bird..."
She wrote tall man, water, bird on a pink note and slid it across the floor to Theo, who read it and toppled sideways, shaking silently.
The next call was a man convinced it was his neighbour, because his neighbour had a suspicious hedge. The one after that was a woman asking if there was a reward. The one after that, thirty seconds of breathing, then a click.
"That's how it goes," Richard murmured, without looking up. "Ninety-nine in a hundred are nothing. You wait for the hundredth."
"What does the hundredth sound like?" Annie asked.
He lifted his eyes, at last. Something moved behind them, tired and old.
"Quiet," he said.
Theo, bless him, rescued the mood. "Just so we're clear," he said, "if the hundredth call is the cat bloke again, I'm resigning."
"The cat's fine," Julian said from the map, not turning round. "He rang twice. He found it in the garage."
"You spoke to the cat bloke?"
"Someone had to."
"He's a saint," Theo told Annie, in a loud whisper. "Don't let him fool you. He's secretly a saint."
Julian shook his head, smiling at the map, and moved a green pin two inches to the left.
They worked until the clock in the hall struck nine. Somewhere under the floor, the dehumidifier droned, a low, constant hum you stopped hearing after an hour. At one point the lights flickered, and Julian said, "Fuse," and disappeared through the kitchen without another word. A door opened. His feet creaked on stairs. A minute later the lights steadied, and he came back wiping his hands on the front of his shirt.
"Those stairs are bad," Richard said, not looking up. "I've told you."
"I'm careful."
"You're not. You're lucky."
Julian only smiled.
When they reached the pin for Cal Reyes, Julian hesitated.
"He had keys," he said. "And he lost his job on Monday. That's... it's hard to ignore."
"The chief likes him," Theo said.
"I'm not saying he did it. I'm saying he's the one with access." Julian stepped back and studied the map with his head tilted. "Honestly I'd want to know more about him."
Annie frowned. "He's twenty-three. I've seen him at the bakery. He looks like he hasn't slept in a week."
"Maybe that's guilt."
"Or maybe it's fear. They look the same from outside." She paused. "I just can't see him doing it. He's too..."
"Too what?"
"Scared," she said. "Whoever's doing this isn't scared."
The room went quiet for a moment.
"You could be right," Julian said mildly. He turned back to the map and nudged the pin a little to one side, without taking it out. "I just think we should keep looking."
At the head of the table, Richard had gone very still, his eyes on Annie, a strange, measuring look on his face. Then he went back to his folder.
There was a knock at the front door, two quick raps. Richard got up to answer, and Annie heard Dana's voice in the hall, low and tired. Dana came to the dining room doorway and stood there a moment, taking in the five of them, the map, the notes, the phone.
She smiled at Annie. Then her gaze moved to Richard, and something flickered over her face, quick and bright and uneasy, the look of someone who has just remembered what she isn't saying.
"Anything?" she asked.
"Psychics," said Richard. "And a hedge."
Dana laughed, a bit too hard.
*
It was past eleven by the time the others had left.
Julian had gone first, a quiet nod and a muttered early start, and the sound of his van starting in the street. Richard had gone up to bed, his steps slow on the stairs, and the whole house settled into the long, creaking quiet of a very old place at night.
Annie stayed to wash the mugs.
She was drying the last one when Theo appeared in the kitchen doorway, holding her bag.
"This fell off the chair," he said. "And I swear I wasn't snooping, but a book fell out, and I want you to know I read the blurb and it's tragic."
"Give me that."
"The Lighthouse Keeper's Daughter." He held it above his head, grinning. "Ooh, three hundred pages. And look, a bookmark. You're on, what, page two-eighty? Two-eighty-seven? You've been on page two-eighty-seven for three weeks. Annie."
"I'm busy."
"You're scared."
She grabbed the book and clutched it to her chest, and her face went hot. "I'm not."
"You are. You do the face." He did it again, brows down, mouth flat. "You get to the end of every book you love and you stop. You stick it in a drawer. It's like you think if you never read the last page nobody has to die."
She opened her mouth to argue and found she couldn't.
"I just don't want it to be over," she said at last, in a small voice. "Is that stupid?"
Theo looked at her. The jokes drained slowly out of his face, and what was left was only kindness.
"Come here," he said.
They sat on the kitchen floor with their backs to the cupboards, because that was where they were, and Theo took the book from her and found the page. She watched him flick through the last chapter.
"Right. I'll read it. I'll read the last page, and you don't have to look, you just have to listen. Deal?"
"Deal."
"I'm doing voices."
"Theo."
"The lighthouse keeper is a pirate."
"He's not a pirate."
"He is now."
He cleared his throat and read the last page in a growl, with a dreadful accent, raising his eyebrows at all the wrong words. The lighthouse keeper's daughter said goodbye to the sea like a woman with a ship to catch. The old man said arrr in a tender moment. She laughed until she had to clap a hand over her mouth.
Then, at the final paragraph, his voice changed.
He dropped the voice. He read the last lines quietly, plainly, in his own, slow and a little rough. The light went on as it always had, and she walked down toward the water, unafraid, because someone had once told her that being left was not the same as being alone.
He shut the book.
The kitchen was very quiet. Somewhere in the walls, the old house ticked and settled.
Annie realised she was crying. Not much, just a few tears running quietly down her cheeks, and she wiped them away with the heel of her hand, embarrassed.
Theo didn't crack a joke. "Your hands are freezing," he said eventually.
"They're always freezing."
"That's a medical condition. You should see someone."
"It's called living in a bad flat."
He reached over and took her hands. He didn't ask. He just did it, the way you do something you've thought about for a long time and finally stopped talking yourself out of. He folded both of hers into both of his and held them there, between them, on the cold tiles.
His palms were warm. A bit rough. She looked down, because it was easier than looking up, and noticed a small, pink, healing mark on the inside of his wrist, a burn, shaped like a thin bar.
"What's that?"
"Oven." He didn't look at it. "Workplace hazard."
"The ones at the shop don't get hot."
"These ones are ambitious."
She smiled. He smiled back, and his thumb moved, slowly, over her knuckles, back and forth, as if he were smoothing out something that had been creased for years.
The fridge hummed. The clock in the hall ticked, then ticked again. Neither of them spoke, and the silence didn't feel empty. It felt crowded with things neither of them was brave enough to say, and she thought, If I look up now, something is going to happen.
She looked up.
He was already looking at her.
"Annie," he said. His voice was softer than she'd ever heard it. "I—"
She waited. Her heart was pounding so hard she was sure he could feel it through her fingers.
He swallowed. His eyes dropped to their hands, then back to her face, and something in his expression wobbled, and held.
"Your hands," he said, "are still cold."
She let out a breath that was half a laugh. "I noticed."
"I'm working on it."
"You're doing very well."
"Thank you. I'm a professional."
They sat a while longer, hands folded together, both pretending nothing had almost been said.
At the end of the hall, in the dim light from the stairs, a shape moved. She looked up and saw Julian by the coat rack, one arm in his jacket, the other still holding his keys. He must have come back for something. He'd stopped there, perfectly still, looking down the length of the hall into the kitchen.
He met her eyes.
He smiled, a small, warm, unreadable smile, and raised a hand.
"Forgot my scarf," he said softly.
He took it from the hook and went out without another word, and the front door shut behind him very gently, the way you close a door on a sleeping house.
Theo's hand was still on hers. She turned her palm up, and he laced their fingers together, and for a long time nobody said anything at all. Theo raised his hands to her soft cheeks, which had gone red. He looked into her eyes and they held each other's gaze for as long as it takes ice to melt. He leaned in to look closer, but Annie broke the silence: "It's getting late." He nodded and walked her home, still holding her hand.
*
The next morning she ate breakfast off the blue-rimmed plate.
She felt slightly ridiculous. Toast and a boiled egg, laid out like a ceremony, on a plate that belonged to someone with a whole life behind it. She ate slowly, with the radio on, and watched the rain run down the window above the brick wall.
She smiled to herself remembering last night, and her heart fluttered. A feeling so strange and yet so lovely.
She picked up her phone to text.
Annie: Thank you for the plates. Really. I used one. It felt like a miracle.
She'd sent it to both of them, and hit send before she could stop herself.
Theo: [ten emojis in a row, including a plate, a crying face, and what she could only guess was a pirate]
Julian: Anytime.
That was all. Just one word, plain, a full stop at the end like a hand gently closing a door.
She looked at it for a moment, and smiled, and put the phone face down.
It was only later, rinsing the plate at the sink, that she thought of the look on his face when he'd seen the single mug. She thought of how quickly he'd left, and how he had never once, in all the years she'd known him, taken credit for anything.
He's the kindest person I know, she thought.
She put the plate on the rack, and went to find her coat.
*
Him
He is humming, and doesn't realise.
It is late, and the house above him is dark. The work is nearly finished, and there is a peace in it that he has never been able to explain, a stillness he finds nowhere else. The mortar is the right thickness. His hands know what to do. He lays the last course with the care of a man who was taught that things done properly are done once.
Behind the wall is someone who once looked straight through him.
He doesn't think about their face. He tried that, at the start, and found it did nothing for him. What matters is the quiet, the finish. He smooths the surface with the flat of the trowel, patient and slow. The wall, when he steps back, is plain and square and forgettable. It looks as though it has always been there.
He stands for a long time, wiping his hands on his sleeve.
Somewhere above him, a floorboard creaks, and he stops humming and holds completely still, head tilted, listening. Then the house settles again, and he lets out a breath he hadn't known he was holding.
He switches off the light, climbs the stairs, and doesn't look back.