The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 3 · 3. Theo

Chapter 3

3. Theo

10 min read

Theo had been explaining the difference between a convection oven and an ordinary one for eleven minutes when his phone buzzed in his back pocket.

"So the fan," he told the woman in front of him, "is basically doing what you'd do if you stood beside your food and blew on it. With feeling. For forty minutes."

"I don't need all that," she said. "I just want to know if it's any good."

"It's good." He leaned closer. "It's really good. It's the oven I'd marry, if I were the type of man who married ovens."

She stared at him for a long moment. Then she laughed in spite of herself, and bought it.

Theo did a little victory shuffle behind the till, checked his manager wasn't watching, and fished out his phone.

The group chat was already twenty messages deep.

Annie: Have you seen the news? Gordon Pryce from the tire place is missing.

Annie: He didn't open the shop Saturday.. Or Sunday. They're saying no one's seen him since Friday night.

Julian: Saw it. Hope he's alright.

Theo scrolled up. Then down. Then he did what he always did when something felt too big to hold, which was to stick a joke in front of it like a small, flimsy shield.

Theo: Gordon? Gordon who once charged me $40 to "look" at my tyre? That Gordon?

Theo: He's in Florida. He's on a boat. He's wearing a tiny hat.

Annie: Theo.

Theo: What? I'm being optimistic.

Julian: He's probably fine.

Annie: He used to give me free air for my tyres when I couldn't pay.

Theo's thumb hung over the screen. The joke had stopped being funny somewhere between the first message and the last. He deleted the one he'd been about to send, then typed a different one.

Theo: Lunch at the usual spot? My treat. Tea for you.

Annie: You don't have to.

Theo: I know. Noon.

He put the phone away and looked at the new oven, shining under the shop lights, and for some reason he didn't feel like winking at it any more.

*

The café across from the shop had a chalkboard menu, five tables, and a waitress called Pat who called everybody "sweetheart" in the precise tone of a woman who would remember if you didn't tip.

Annie was already there, in the corner seat by the window, coat still on. She looked small, somehow, in the winter light. Theo dropped into the chair opposite and slid a paper cup across the table.

"Lemon and ginger," he said. "No sugar. You hate it when they add sugar without asking."

She blinked at the cup, then at him. "How do you remember that?"

"It's a gift. Tragically, my only one." He leaned back, grinning. "I can't remember my own mum's birthday, but I know you hate sugar, you're allergic to nothing, and you read the last page of every book first."

"I don't read the last page first."

"You do. You think no one notices. You make this face." He made the face: brows down, mouth pressed flat, a woman who has just made a terrible choice. "Like you're sneaking a look at your own funeral."

She laughed, and he felt a small, absurd glow of triumph, the kind he'd get from landing a great punchline in front of a very tough crowd.

"Tell me about the lake," she said.

"Oh no." He clutched his chest theatrically. "Oh, you don't want to hear about the lake."

"I do."

"There was a gravy incident, Annie."

So he told her. How his sister's new boyfriend, a tall, jumpy man named Marcus with the posture of someone waiting to be arrested, had got through thirteen of his dad's fourteen questions with real grace, and then been destroyed completely by number nine. How his dad had leaned back in his chair and asked, in the voice of a judge about to pass sentence, "And what is your position on gravy?" How Marcus had said, after a long and painful pause, "I think it's a good... sauce."

"A sauce," Theo said. "Like a man narrating his own tragedy. Mum had to leave the room. My sister cried. Not from sadness. From pure, unholy joy."

Annie was laughing so hard she had to set her tea down. Pat glanced over from the counter, smiling.

"And then," Theo said, wiping his eyes, "the next morning, Marcus came down for breakfast, and Dad handed him a spatula and said, 'You'll do.' That's it. That's the whole blessing. A spatula."

"That's actually sweet."

"It's the sweetest thing my dad has ever done. I was jealous."

He hadn't meant to say that last bit. It came out lighter than it felt, tossed away like a joke. He watched Annie's smile soften at the edges, and for a moment neither of them spoke.

She was looking at him. Just looking, a beat longer than the laugh deserved, her eyes steady and a bit far away, as if she were memorising something.

He decided it was the lemon on his face.

"What?" he said, rubbing his chin. "Have I got gravy on me?"

"No." She lowered her eyes to her cup. "Nothing."

Theo coughed and reached for his own tea, which had gone cold.

"Oh," Annie said, as if something had just come back to her. "I rang you Friday night. Twice. Where were you?"

The cup froze halfway to his mouth.

"Home," Theo said. "Phone died. Pizza. Thrilling night, honestly, you missed nothing."

It came out quickly, a bit too smooth, like a line he'd practised in the mirror. Annie's gaze dropped to his hands around the cup, and her nose crinkled slightly.

"You smell of onions."

"It's the shop," he said. "Workplace hazard. Very pungent ovens."

"Ovens don't smell of onions."

"These do. They're ambitious."

She tipped her head. For a second she looked like she might press him. Then she let it drop, the way she let most things drop., and picked up her tea. Theo, who had never been more relieved in his life, launched with no warning into a bit about Pat the waitress and her long-running feud with the sugar dispenser, louder and longer than the joke merited. Annie smiled and let him, and said nothing about the way he wouldn't quite meet her eyes.

"Anyway," he said at last, slightly out of breath. "Jules sent me a photo from Dad's basement on Sunday. Did you see?"

"No."

"He spent the whole weekend on that wall. He sent me this picture of himself, plaster up to his elbows, grey all over, looking like a very depressed ghost." Theo shook his head, fond. "He's scary when he commits to something. He finished it in two days. Dad said it'd take a month."

"That's Julian," Annie said.

"That's Julian," Theo agreed.

*

They took the long way back, along the canal, because Annie said she wasn't ready to go back to work and Theo said he'd been fired from nothing and so had nowhere to be.

The air was cold and clear. The trees along the towpath were bare, their branches laced with thin winter sun. A little way ahead, a woman was pinning a sheet of paper to the noticeboard by the footbridge, smoothing it flat against the wood with both hands.

They slowed as they went past.

MISSING, the sheet read, in thick black letters. Underneath, a photo: a stocky, grey-haired man in a work jacket, squinting at the camera with the look of someone who'd been asked to smile and had refused. GORDON PRYCE, 56. Last seen Friday evening. Please call.

Annie stopped.

"He gave me a voucher once," she said. "For a free oil change. I told him I didn't have a car and he said 'you will.'" She laughed, a thin little sound. "I do now. Sort of."

Theo said nothing for a moment. He had a joke ready. He had several. He could feel them queued up behind his teeth, bright and handy, and for once he didn't reach for any of them.

"He's probably fine," he said finally, quietly. "He probably just needed a break from tyres."

"You don't believe that."

"No." He looked at the photo. "But I want to. Is that alright?"

She turned and looked at him, and her whole face shifted, softened, as if he'd handed her something she hadn't known she needed.

"You do that," she said.

"Do what?"

"Make things lighter. Even when it's... when it isn't."

"It's my only skill," Theo said. "That and ruining soup."

"It's not your only skill."

"No?"

"No."

The wind picked up. A strand of hair slipped free of her scarf and she tucked it back with cold fingers, and Theo, who had never once in his life been short of words, found that every one of them had abandoned him at the same moment.

Say it, something inside him whispered. Say something. Anything.

He opened his mouth, his hands almost moving forward to take hers.

His phone buzzed.

They both jumped. Theo laughed too loudly, pulled it out, and squinted at the screen.

Julian: Where are you two? Dad's making soup. Real soup. Apparently it's an event.

"It's Jules," Theo said, and heard how odd his voice sounded. "Soup."

"Of course it is."

"He's like a mother hen," Theo said, thumbing a reply. "He always knows where we are. I swear he's put a tracker in my coat."

"He's the only one of us who's actually got his life sorted," Annie said, a little wistfully.

"That's the creepiest thing you've ever said."

"It was a compliment."

"I know." Theo grinned. "That's why it's creepy."

She laughed and knocked his arm with her shoulder. They walked on side by side, close enough that their sleeves brushed, and neither of them looked back at the flyer.

*

By evening, half of Alder Street had packed into the hall behind the church.

Theo had expected a handful of people. Instead there were forty or fifty, standing in loose groups under the strip lights, talking in the low, uneasy voices of people who didn't yet know if they were scared. Someone had put out a coffee urn. Someone else had brought a plate of biscuits and then apologised for it, as though biscuits were the wrong thing to bring to a disaster.

He found Julian by the doors, a pile of paper in his arms.

"You printed all these?" Theo said.

"Two hundred. Laminated forty." Julian handed him a bundle without being asked. "Clear photo, big type, phone number at the bottom. People ignore the ones with tiny writing."

Theo leafed through them. They were perfect: clean lines, bold type, a photo that actually looked like the man. Beside them, the hand-drawn sheets pinned to the corkboard looked like ransom notes written by kids.

"When did you do this?"

"After work." Julian shrugged. "Someone had to."

That was it, of course. That was always it. Someone had to, and someone always did, and it was always Julian.

Theo watched him move through the room. He did it without effort, the way a good host does., never looking rushed. He sorted the neighbours into groups by street. He gave one woman a map and showed her where to begin. He crouched beside an old man in a wheelchair, said something Theo couldn't catch, and the old man nodded, visibly calmer, and took a bundle of flyers in both hands like a sacred task.

People leaned toward him as he went by. They did it without thinking, the way plants lean toward a window.

"Pryce was a decent man," someone muttered by the urn.

"Heard he owed money."

"Heard he had a row with someone Friday."

"Heard he left a note."

The voices rose and knotted together. Theo caught bits and pieces, rumours passing mouth to mouth like a cold. And through all of it, Julian said nothing. He listened, nodded, kept handing out paper. He never added a theory or passed on a story, never asked a single question about the missing man.

Which was just Julian. Julian didn't gossip. He had never in his life said a cruel word about anyone behind their back.

Theo caught up with him as the groups started filing out into the dark.

"You're a saint, you know that?"

"Hardly." Julian smiled, tired and warm. "I'm just trying to be useful."

"That's what saints say."

"That's what people say when they've got nothing better to do."

Theo laughed and elbowed him, and Julian raised a hand to catch the elbow, and for a moment, in the light by the door., Theo's eyes dropped to his friend's fingers.

Under the nails, in the creases of the knuckles, there was a faint, stubborn greyness. A fine, pale dust that hadn't quite washed out.

"You've still got the wall under your nails," Theo said.

Julian looked down at his hand. He turned it over, almost curious, as if seeing it for the first time.

"It'll come out," he said.

"It's been two days."

"Plaster's stubborn." He smiled again, and the smile was exactly the same as ever. "So are you."

Then he clapped Theo on the shoulder and stepped out into the cold, the stack of paper under his arm, calling goodnight to a neighbour across the road.

Theo lingered in the doorway a moment longer. The hall was emptying behind him. Somewhere in the dark a dog was barking, and the wind carried the sound of voices calling a name, again and again, down every street in town.

Gordon. Gordon Pryce. Has anyone seen Gordon?

He pulled his coat tighter and went to catch up with his friends, and felt, despite everything, ridiculously and completely lucky.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.