The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 14 · 14. It's Not You

Chapter 14

14. It's Not You

13 min read

They had taken Julian at dusk, and by nine Annie had counted every minute since.

She sat on a plastic chair in the station's front office with her coat in her lap and her eyes on the clock above the desk sergeant's head, and every time the minute hand moved, she thought: that's one more. Richard had rung at half six, in a voice she didn't recognise. She and Theo had run the whole way.

It was an arrest. Dana had said the word herself, in the gentle, careful voice of someone who's been told what to say, and then said it again, as if that would make it true. They'll question him tonight. You can wait, if you like. I can't tell you how long. So they waited, under the glare of the lights, while something that had been unthinkable at lunchtime settled into the room like furniture.

Theo sat beside her. He hadn't stopped moving since they arrived. First he'd tried jokes, and when those fell flat, he'd tried silence, and then he'd gone for coffee, three times, and come back each time with two paper cups he forgot to hand to anyone.

"It's absurd," he said, for the tenth time. "It's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Julian. Julian? He apologises to furniture."

"I know."

"He saves spiders."

"I know, Theo."

"They think a man who carries spiders out of the house in a cup has been..." He stopped and put his head in his hands. "I can't even say it. It's so insane I can't even joke about it."

“I can understand, Theo. I am equally disappointed. We’ve seen Julian all our lives and he’s never done a single thing wrong. He’s just too perfect.” Annie said.

Theo looked hesitant at first but later put his head on her shoulder. Annie let him. He had been running and trying to do everything he can for Julian. Annie could feel the weight of his head but didn’t move an inch. She could smell his aftershave and deodorant.

“He’ll be fine right, Annie?” he looked at her with eyes of hope.

“Of course he will. It’s Jules after all.”

Theo had shifted from Annie’s shoulder to her lap. She ruffled his hair until he fell asleep. He looks even younger and innocent when he sleeps like that. Annie thought.

At the end of the row, in a chair against the wall, Richard sat with his hands on his knees. He hadn't spoken in two hours. He looked as though something had been taken out of him, quietly, a bit at a time, and what was left had been folded very small. Every so often his lips moved, without a sound.

Annie got up carefully and placed her jacket under Theo’s head. Theo woke up due to the shift.

“Did Jules come?”

“Not yet. Stay here. Let me go check Dad. he doesn't seem fine.” Annie said and Theo nodded before pulling Annie’s jacket on his face.

She went over to Richard, and sat beside him. After a moment she took his hand.

It was cold and dry as paper. He didn't look at her. But his fingers closed round hers, slowly, and held on.

"He didn't do it," she said.

"No."

"You know that."

"I know."

"Then why do you look like that?"

He turned his head. His eyes were red-rimmed and very tired, and for a moment he seemed to be looking at her from a great distance, from the far side of something she couldn't see.

"Because it doesn't matter what I know," he said. "That's what thirty years teaches you, Annie. It never matters what you know. It only matters what you can prove."

She didn't answer. There was nothing to say.

At twenty past nine, the door at the end of the corridor opened. Dana came out first, her face drawn. Then Julian, with a constable a step behind.

He walked slowly, as if the floor might not be level. His shirt was creased and his collar open, and there was a grey, hollow look under his eyes she'd never seen before.

All three of them were on their feet before he'd crossed the room.

Annie reached him first. She flung her arms round his neck, and he stood stiff for half a breath and then gave way, his face dropping into her hair. Theo came in from the side and wrapped them both. Richard got there last, slowly, one hand pressed flat to his chest, and put his arms round as much of the three of them as he could reach, and said nothing at all.

Nobody spoke. The constable studied the wall.

When they finally let go, none of them let go completely. Annie took one of Julian's hands, and Theo the other, and Richard laid his palm over the knot of their fingers and kept it there. Julian looked down at the four hands, at the grazed knuckles and the grey under the nails, and something crossed his face.

"They want to see my books," he said, in a perfectly level voice.

"Your books?" said Theo.

"Receipts. Invoices. Every job I've done in six months." A thin, odd smile. "I haven't got any."

"You haven't got any," Theo repeated.

"I take cash." Julian sank into a chair and rubbed his face with both hands. "Half my clients are old ladies with envelopes. They pay me cash on the doorstep and give me a biscuit. No one writes anything down. I'm... I'm hopeless with paperwork. Dad's been telling me for years. I keep the numbers in my head."

"Julian."

"I know."

"You can't keep forty bags of plaster in your head."

"I never thought I'd need to." His voice rose, cracked, dropped again. He pressed his knuckles to his mouth. "Sorry. I'm sorry. I'm so tired."

Annie looked at him. She'd known him six years. In all that time, she'd seen him angry maybe twice, and each time it had been small and controlled, a tightening at the corner of the mouth, gone in a moment. Now he sat slumped in a plastic chair, hair on end, hands shaking, and she realised she had never once seen him afraid.

He's perfect, a small, unwelcome voice said at the back of her mind. He's always been perfect. Isn't that strange?

She shoved it away. She shoved it so hard it hurt.

"Okay," she said. "We'll make them."

Everyone looked at her.

"Receipts. Invoices. We'll build them." She was already on her feet, pulling out her phone. "Who are your clients? All of them. Names, addresses, what you did. We'll go to every one."

"Annie, that's..."

"Mrs Ames. The gutter. The bakery on Pine. You did their back wall in October. Who was the other woman, the one with the greenhouse?"

"Mrs Vale." A slow, dazed pause. "Mrs Vale. She gave me a lemon cake."

"Great. Mrs Vale. Theo, find some paper."

Theo was already up. "I can find paper. I can find anything. I once found a lost ring in a sewer."

"That's not..."

"It was a metaphorical sewer."

The constable cleared his throat. "That's time, miss."

Dana, who had been standing very still at the edge of the group, took a notepad from her pocket and held it out to Julian without a word. "Write them down," she said quietly. "Everyone you can think of. I'll make sure they're asked."

He wrote for a full minute, in his heavy, blocky hand, pressing so hard the pen tore the page. Then he ripped it free, gave it to Annie, and let the constable take his arm. At the door he looked back, once. Then the corridor swallowed him.

*

By ten they had a table in the corner of the front office, with a legal pad, three pens, and a long, uneven list in Julian's blocky writing. By eleven, Theo had borrowed a station phone and was working his way down it in his best, warmest, most disarming voice. Hello, Mrs Vale? No, nothing's wrong. I'm calling on behalf of Julian Wright. Yes, the plasterer. Would you mind terribly if the police asked you a few questions?

By midnight, the first of them had turned up.

It was Mrs Ames, in a mac and a plastic rain hood, gripping a handbag the size of a small suitcase. She marched to the desk and announced to the sergeant that she was here to give a statement about the character of Mr Julian Wright, and that she would not be leaving until she had.

"He fixed my gutter," she said. "Twice. He wouldn't take a penny the second time."

"Madam, if you'd just..."

"He carried my shopping up four flights when I broke my hip. He's the nicest young man in this town. If you think he's done anything wrong, you're a fool, and you can tell the chief I said so."

Annie covered her mouth. Beside her, Theo was making a small, helpless, joyful sound, somewhere between a sob and a laugh.

They kept coming, all through the small hours. Mrs Vale with her greenhouse and a tin of lemon cake. The woman from the bakery on Pine, still in her apron, flour on her elbows. A thin man with a stammer who ran the hardware shop on the east side, and who said, after a long struggle, that Julian had never once been late with a job, or short with a customer, or rude to anyone, and that he bought his lime in bulk, for jobs all over town, because it was cheaper that way, and that he'd watched him load that van at Dunmore's more times than he could count.

"Cheaper that way," Theo whispered. "He should put that on a plaque."

One by one, they sat at the little table and gave their names, and Dana wrote them down. Twelve jobs. Fifteen. Eighteen. The lime and the brick and the mortar, spread across half the town, in sheds and kitchens and back walls and garden paths. Nobody had receipts. Nobody had needed them. They'd simply trusted him.

At ten past four in the morning, Dana put down her pen, looked at the long, crowded table and the queue of faces behind it, and said, in a voice not quite steady:

"I think that'll do."

*

They didn't let him go.

Brandt came out of his office at half four to say so himself. He stood at the end of the corridor with his hands in his pockets, a grey, tight, unhappy man who hadn't expected to be besieged all night by handbags and lemon cake. "I have your statements," he said. "The lime is accounted for. I'll grant that." A pause. "The coat is not. Mr Wright will stay in custody pending further enquiries. I'll review it in the morning."

"You've got eighteen people," said Theo. "You've got a woman in a rain hood."

"I have a coat with the dust of that building on it."

"There are a thousand of those coats."

"So I'm told." He said it mildly. But his eyes rested on Annie a moment too long, and she felt, rather than saw, the small, cold, patient suspicion in them. Not finished, that look said. Not by a long way.

He turned away. A moment later the door at the end of the corridor opened again, and two officers brought Julian down toward the cells. Dana, behind them, said very low, "Thirty seconds," and looked at the ceiling.

He stopped in front of them. His shirt was creased, his collar open. In the hard light his hands were red-knuckled and scraped, grey under the nails, and she saw him look at the stain with a strange, faint, baffled disgust, as if it were something he'd never seen before.

"I heard," he said. "Through the wall. All of it. Mrs Ames. I could hear her shouting." His mouth trembled. "I wanted to say thank you. Both of you. I don't..." He stopped. "I don't know how to."

"Don't," said Annie.

"I should."

"You'd have done the same."

"That's not..."

"Julian." She stepped closer. "We're your family."

His face did something strange. It was brief, a flicker, quick and bright and painful, like a flame in a draught. For a moment he looked at her, and something hung in his eyes, wide open and unguarded. Then it was gone, and he was smiling, tired and gentle.

"Yeah," he said. "I know."

"Stop looking at me like that," she said, and then flushed. "I mean... like you're about to cry."

"I'm not."

"You are."

"I'm not."

His voice cracked. He turned his face away, fast, and for a moment his shoulders shook, one hard silent shudder. Annie put her arms round him. After a second, Theo did too, so the three of them stood under the buzzing lights in a clumsy, lopsided knot, holding on, while the officers studied the wall.

"I'm going to prove it," said Theo, into Julian's shoulder.

"Prove what?"

"That it's not you. That it's someone else. I'm going to find out who." His voice was muffled, furious, and very young. "I don't care how long it takes."

"Theo. Don't."

"Too late. I've decided."

"Please don't."

"I'm very stubborn. Ask anyone."

Julian let out a long, shaky breath that was half a laugh and half something else. He didn't argue. He closed his eyes, stood very still, and let them hold him.

"Time," said Dana softly.

They took him away. He didn't look back.

Outside, the sky was turning grey, and a thin rain had started. Richard was standing by the station door with his collar up, as if he'd been there for hours. He hadn't been in the corridor. Annie realised, vaguely, that he hadn't gone near it all night.

"Go home," he said. His voice was very quiet. "Both of you. Sleep."

"Dad..." said Theo.

"Please."

He set off across the car park with his head down, a small grey figure in the rain, and the two of them watched him go.

"He's not okay," Theo said softly.

"No."

"None of us are."

*

It was past five when she got home, and the sky was going pale over the rooftops.

The flat was cold and silent. She stood in the doorway a moment, keys in hand, and let the day drain out of her, then kicked off her shoes and went to the kitchen to put the kettle on.

Three mugs sat on the draining rack. Two plain, white, ordinary ones, upside down. And between them, slightly crooked, with its handle too high, a third.

She took it down. She held it in both hands.

T + A, in wobbly blue paint, the A a bit backwards and the T dripping.

It was a silly, lopsided thing. He'd spent three hours on it and been asked to leave twice. And now, in the cold quiet of her kitchen, with rain on the window and the day behind her like a bruise, it was the only thing in the room that felt solid.

He's going to do something reckless, she thought. He always does.

She made the tea in the mug. She sat at the table with her coat still on, because she was too tired to take it off, wrapped both hands round the warmth, and tried not to think about the small, cold voice at the back of her head.

Isn't it strange, how perfect he is?

Isn't it strange how his face goes blank?

Isn't it strange how he never, ever asks for anything?

She pressed the heel of her hand to her eyes. It was a ridiculous thing to think. It was a wicked thing to think, after tonight, after all those people, all that kindness, an old woman in a rain hood shouting at a policeman because she loved him. She was ashamed of herself. Ashamed that the thought had come at all.

She got up to take her coat off, put a hand in the pocket for a tissue, and found paper.

She frowned.

It was a small piece, folded in four, creased and soft from handling. She drew it out and unfolded it under the kitchen light. A page torn from a notebook. A familiar, scrawling, hurried hand.

image

She read it once. Then she sat down on the kitchen floor, because her legs had stopped working, and read it again.

It had been in her pocket for a week. She'd worn that coat to the station. She'd walked to the bakery in it. She'd sat all night in a plastic chair with the paper pressed against her hip, and she hadn't known.

She laughed, once, a wet, cracked, helpless sound. And then she was crying, quietly, knees drawn up and the note held to her chest in both hands, the mug on the floor beside her, cooling, forgotten.

I love you, he had written. I love you. I love you.

She wiped her eyes. She smoothed the note flat on her knee, folded it again, carefully, along the same old creases, and tucked it into the pocket of her dress, over her heart, where it was warm.

He's going to do something reckless, she thought again.

But this time there was something else under it. A small, quiet, steady thing, like a light left on in a faraway room.

So am I.

Her phone buzzed on the table.

She picked it up. It was Theo.

Theo: Can't sleep. Thinking about Jules. Thinking about the ledger.

Theo: Don't argue with me. I've got an idea.

Theo: I'll tell you later. Sleep. That's an order. From a professional.

She looked at the screen for a long moment. Then she typed, with a small, tired smile:

Annie: Goodnight, Theo.

Annie: I love you too.

She sent it before she could think. And then she sat in the quiet kitchen with the phone in her hand and the rain on the glass, and waited for the three dots to appear.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.