The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 17 · 17. Nine Days

Chapter 17

17. Nine Days

8 min read

The phone rang at ten to six.

Richard was sitting at the kitchen table in his coat. He'd been there since two, since Julian was taken home to sleep and he came back alone. The pan Julian had been stirring on Friday still sat cold on the stove, the spoon in it.

He answered.

"Detective?"

A small, hoarse voice. It took him a second. "Eddie."

"Sorry to ring. I've remembered something. About Gordon, and the shop. And about a woman called Claire."

Richard didn't move.

"Where are you?"

"Harlow. The old godown. I can't say it over the phone. I don't trust the police. Please come on your own. I'll wait by the road."

He had drilled it into young officers a hundred times: never go alone. He had a rule for it.

"I'll come," he said.

He put down the receiver, walked into the front room, and stopped in front of the mantelpiece. He hadn't looked at the photograph in fifteen years. A dark-haired woman, laughing, head thrown back, laughing at someone just outside the frame.

Claire.

"I'm going to see what he knows," he told her.

He took his keys. He told himself it was for the case, because that was the sentence he could stand.

It wasn't.

*

Eddie was waiting by the roadside under the one broken streetlamp, a carrier bag at his feet. They walked across the rutted ground together, without a word, to the sliding door. It stood a hand's width open.

"I don't understand," Richard said, stopping at the threshold. "Why here?"

"Because I wanted to show you," said Eddie. His voice was flat and steady. "I've waited a long time. You'll see."

It was cold inside, and almost dark. A last grey light came down through the broken skylight onto the long bare floor.

Eddie walked ahead of him and stopped near the middle.

"Here."

Richard knew the spot. A patch of concrete the size of a doormat, slightly darker than the rest. He had spent fifteen years not looking at it.

"She came here on a Thursday evening," Eddie said. "She'd been asking questions for a month. Someone told her where to look. She knew they'd kept somebody here, and she came to see if it was true." He looked at the floor. "You were the first one through that door the next morning. You stood where you're standing now."

"Who are you?" Richard whispered.

Eddie didn't answer. He turned to the long brick wall at the back and laid his hand flat on it.

"You see these walls? Every one of them, I plastered in like a showpiece. I put them in there and let the cement set round them. They're all still here."

Richard's knees went weak.

"Gordon. He turned the radio up so nobody would hear me screaming, and locked the back door. Marianne, who laughed when I begged her to stop pulling at my skin. Harold Benning, who kept a tally in a notebook so they'd never lose count of the days they had their fun."

He said it the way you'd read out a list.

"Leonard Voss brought me water and never once told them to stop. He drank it in front of me instead, and left me desperate for a drop, so I left him on the bridge where somebody would finally look. And Ernie? He wasn't one of them. He asked too many questions. He was just in the way."

Richard stood very still. The words came one at a time, and he understood every one, and some part of him kept saying: No. He held a cup of tea. He said thank you.

"You," he said.

"Me."

"You sat in that station. And the boy, Julian, they found a coat..."

"That was luck," said Eddie. "It was never going to be him. He had nothing to do with it."

He stepped into the last of the light.

"Look at me. Properly."

Richard looked. A thin, weathered face. Pale grey eyes. Hands that didn't know where to rest. And something in him gave way, quietly, like a plank over water.

A boy at the end of a picnic table, in a shirt too big for him, staring straight into a camera.

I've looked at that face a hundred times. I could never place it.

"She called me Edward," said Eddie.

He said it aloud, clearly. The name rang faintly off the iron roof.

"When I was in trouble. Edward. And Eddie when I wasn't."

"Edward," said Richard. He had never read the name on the back of the photograph. He didn't need to. "You died! She told me! We found a coat by the river."

"I ran."

"I thought you were dead. I swear it."

"I know you did."

He didn't remember sitting down. He was on an upturned crate against the wall, hands between his knees.

"You want to ask me why," said Eddie.

"I know why. I've read some of what she wrote."

"You don't know!" Eddie's voice pitched higher. "They had me nine days. Nine whole days! They did whatever they liked, because it was funny. That's what she never understood. She kept asking why, and who, and what happened, as if there'd be a reason. But there wasn't one. They were just bored, all six of them."

He looked at his hands.

“I was a child. All I wanted was to go back home. Every time I heard footsteps, I used to think someone has finally come to save me. But no! It was always the six of them. For all those nine days it was just them! They came, did what they wanted to and left.” He looked at him dead in the eye.

"They left me on her doorstep. She found me in the morning. Can you imagine what that was like for her?"

Richard didn’t make a sound.

“She kept touching me. My hands that were bruised. My face that was pale. She looked into my lifeless eyes and kept telling me it’s all okay. I wanted to believe her. God, I wanted to believe her. But do you know what? For the first time I didn’t feel safe even in my mother’s hands.” He sighed.

"But she wouldn't let it go. She kept asking me for their names, asking me where. And I couldn't. There weren't words for it. One night she stood in the kitchen with her hand on my shoulder and said, Edward, please, just tell me one thing. And I... I screamed at her. I said something I can't repeat. And... and I ran. I was thirteen."

"Edward..."

"No! You listen now. Eleven months later, in a bus station, I heard two women talking. That poor detective's wife. They never caught anyone." His voice didn't change. "I came back. I read the file in the library. Nine days, and a stamp. I stood on her grave and understood that I'd killed her. All she ever did was ask me one thing, and I couldn't give it to her, so she went to find it herself and they killed her for it, right here, on this floor, all because I couldn't say a word!"

"You should forgive yourself."

“What do you mean?”

“She didn’t die because of you. It’s not your fault. You are doing all this because you can’t forgive yourself. Stop blaming yourself.”

"Don't! You don't get to say that. Don’t act like you care now. You didn’t do it when you had to. You closed it!"

Richard lifted his head.

"Yes," he said. "I closed it."

"And why?"

He had never said it out loud.

"A week after the funeral, a man left something on my desk. I'd known him twenty years. There was no note. It was a photo of an eight-year-old boy, in school uniform, crossing a road." His throat worked. "The boy was my son."

Eddie said nothing.

"I knew what it meant. I thought you were dead, and I thought they'd killed her, and if I took one more step they'd take the last one I had. So I closed it. I put the file in a box and a blanket over the box. And I told myself every night, for fifteen years, that it was right."

"You traded her. And me. For him."

"Yes."

Eddie stared at him.

For a moment he looked less angry, as though some part of him still expected Richard would deny it.

“Even I was a child, Richard. I was too small for what I had gone through. And all my mother wanted was to give me the justice I deserved. And what did you do? You closed the case. For your son? Was I not someone’s son as well? Wasn’t my mother’s death a reason for you to keep fighting and give her what she died for? Tell me Richard! Tell me.”

Richard was just silent.

"I didn't blame you at first. I thought, he did what any father would." Eddie looked up. His face was calm. "But then I watched you. I saw you happy with your son and I couldn't take it. I don't have a family because you failed! You failed to protect her. You failed to give her the justice she deserved."

Richard closed his eyes.

“Do you feel the regret now Richard?”

“I don’t,” Richard replied with a straight face. “I don’t because I did it to save the last memory of Claire that I had. Julian. My son. Our son. And…”

“I was her SON! I WAS THERE BEFORE JULIAN,” Eddie cut Richard off in the middle.

“Yes, you were, but you had gone. We all thought you died. And I did what I felt was right. And not that I did not try. I kept investigating the people but they threatened me. They told me they’d take away Julian and put me through pain like they took you away from Claire. I couldn’t bear that. He’s the only person I have, with two more children that came afterwards but yes. He’s my son and I did it to protect him.” Richard said.

There was silence in the room.

"Two are left," said Eddie. "Lund and Crane. And one more. Not someone who was in the room. The one who held the key, who could have opened every door in this town, and didn't."

"Me."

"Yes. You."

Richard nodded. There was something almost like relief in it, like putting down a bag he'd carried a very long way.

"Then do it. I won't fight you. But let the others stand trial. Let it be done in the open, where she'd have wanted..."

"She'd have wanted a lot of things, Richard."

A noise came from the far end of the shed: a boot slipping on grit, then a cough.

Eddie went still.

Slowly, from behind the fallen sheets of tin, a figure stood up. Tall, thin, scruffy, a torch in one hand and a crowbar in the other, plaster dust to the elbows.

"Edward," said Theo. His voice shook. He said it again, as if it had finally clicked into place. "Edward Finch. I read it in a ledger. For the Harlow job. Pays in singles. It was you all along."

No, thought Richard. Not him. Anyone but him.

"Step away from him," Theo said. "Please. I really don't want to do this."

Eddie drew a long mason's hammer from inside his coat.

"Keep out of it," he said. "I've got no business with you."

"You do now."

Theo crossed the floor in a rush, clumsy and fast, and put himself between them with his arms spread wide.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.