The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 16 · 16. Ten Bags

Chapter 16

16. Ten Bags

13 min read

"I shouldn't be doing this," said Dana.

"You're not doing anything. I'm just sitting here."

"You're sitting at a police desk with photocopies of evidence in front of you."

"They're very boring photocopies."

She looked at him for a long moment, with the bleak, tired patience of someone who hasn't slept properly in a fortnight. It was quarter to eight on Saturday morning, and the office was nearly empty. Julian had spent the night in a cell downstairs, and everyone in the room knew it and nobody said so. Brandt was at a meeting across town. The coffee machine had just spluttered into life. Theo had brought her a paper cup of something warm and something sugary in a bag, and he was now sitting at a spare desk in the corner with a stack of green-ledger photocopies and the most serious face he could manage.

"Twenty minutes," Dana said at last. "You don't write anything down. You don't take pictures. You don't touch the originals, and if anyone comes in, you were never here."

"I'm a ghost."

"You're an idiot."

"A friendly ghost."

She nearly smiled. She turned away, and he heard her cross the floor to her own desk and sit down heavily, and he bent over the pages with a feeling like a small, cold hand on the back of his neck.

He'd spent most of the night with a notebook and a cup of tea, trying to think. I've got an idea, he'd told Annie. It wasn't an idea. It was a feeling, a sort of splinter. He kept coming back to the ledger. Julian's name on the page, underlined in red, forty bags of this and six hundred of that. Everyone had looked at that line. Everyone had seen Wright, J. and stopped.

But there were a hundred other lines on those pages.

He started at the beginning, and went slowly.

Ernest Fallon's handwriting was small and careful, a neat, forward-leaning pencil. Names, dates, quantities. Mrs Vale, 2 bags, collected. The Pine Street bakery, 12 brick, delivered. Wright, J., 15 lime, collected. Next to some entries, in the margin, he'd added tiny notes in even tinier writing, the way a lonely man talks to himself when he spends his days behind a counter. Wife's birthday. Dog poorly. Always says thank you. A whole life of small observations, filed away for the day someone might want them.

If someone else had been buying plaster in bulk, they'd be in here. That was the idea, such as it was. Not Julian. Someone else.

Theo's eyes moved down the columns. His tea went cold.

On the fourth page, he stopped.

Finch, Edward. Cash. 10 lime. "For the Harlow job." Says the owner's paying him to patch it up. Pays in singles.

He read it twice. It took him a moment. Finch. Then it came back: the corridor, a clipboard, a policewoman's voice saying it aloud. Edward Finch. Witness. Follow-up. The thin man on the bench. Eddie. Of course. He did odd jobs. Anyone would have told you that. A man like that would patch up a ruin for someone who paid him in singles, and he'd need lime.

It's nothing, Theo told himself. It's one name in a hundred.

He carried on down the page. There were other names, other builders, a bricklayer from the east side with an account as long as Julian's. He turned three more pages, and nothing jumped out, and the feeling in his neck didn't go away. When he reached the last sheet he sat back and rubbed his eyes.

Finch, Edward.

It sat in his head like a small stone. It wasn't suspicion. He didn't have enough to be suspicious. It was only a name he'd read and couldn't put down.

"Dana," he said. "I need food or I'll die. Back in ten minutes. I'll be a ghost the whole way."

She waved a hand without looking up.

*

The street outside was cold and bright and full of ordinary people.

He walked to the corner with his hands in his pockets and his head down, thinking about nothing, which was something he almost never did. A woman passed with a pram. A boy on a bike rang his bell. The sandwich shop was across the road, and he was looking at his phone, trying to remember what Annie had said about the ledger the night before, when a thin man in layered coats passed him on the pavement going the other way.

He didn't look at him. He didn't see his face. He got an impression of a carrier bag and a pair of frayed cuffs and a slight, stooped shoulder, and then the man was behind him, and there was only the noise of the street.

And then, very faint, nearly under the traffic, a few thin notes.

A little climb. A little fall.

Theo stopped dead.

He knew it. It reached into him and found the exact spot where he'd lost it, the night of the birthday, with the clock ticking in the hall and a girl in the doorway with her arms full of plates. Sorry. I do that. The radio, he'd told himself. The bus. Some shop.

It wasn't the radio.

He spun round.

The pavement behind him was empty. A woman with a pram, far down toward the bridge. A boy on a bike. The wind pushing a paper cup along the gutter. No man. No coat. He walked back twenty yards and looked in the doorway of a chemist's and down the alley beside the bank, and there was no one there at all.

He stood in the middle of the pavement with his heart going oddly fast.

You're tired, he told himself. You haven't slept. You're hearing things.

But he knew that tune. And he knew exactly where he'd last heard it, and it wasn't a radio, and he wanted, very badly, to ask her.

He typed with his thumb, standing in the cold, outside a chemist's.

Theo: Random question. That tune you hum. Where'd you learn it?

The reply came before he'd put the phone away.

Annie: What tune?

Theo: At your birthday. When you were clearing plates. Four notes up and a little dip.

Annie: Oh. My dad's. He used to hum it while he cooked. I think he sang it to me and my brother when we were little. I don't really remember. Why?

Theo read it once.

He read it again.

My brother.

He had known her six years. She had never once, in all that time, mentioned a brother.

Theo: You've got a brother?

Annie: Had. He died when I was little. I barely remember him. Dad never really talked about it.

Annie: Theo, what's going on? You're being weird.

His thumb hovered over the screen. A cold wind came down the road and rattled the sign above the chemist's.

Don't be ridiculous, he thought. It's a tune. A man can pick up a tune in a hundred places. A drifter picks up songs from pub doorways. A dead boy can't hum. And anyway, he told himself, it was probably nothing, a thin man in a coat, a passing stranger who happened to know an old song.

Theo: Nothing. Just thinking about birthdays. Love you. Sleep.

Annie: You're a terrible liar.

Theo: Professionally.

He bought a sandwich he didn't want. He ate half of it on the station steps, in the thin sun, watching the road, and didn't see the thin man again.

*

They released Julian at ten past two.

Theo was in the corridor, pretending to read a notice, when it happened. Brandt came out of the lift with a folder under his arm and the look of a man who has lost an argument with a handbag and a lemon cake and isn't yet ready to admit it. "There is insufficient evidence to charge at this stage," he said, to no one in particular. "Mr Wright is free to go. He'll remain available for further enquiries. He will not leave town."

Julian came out of the custody door a minute later, grey and blinking, his belt in his hand. Annie was waiting at the end of the corridor with Richard. She didn't say anything. She put her arms round him, and he put his face into her hair, and Theo, watching from the noticeboard, was surprised by how sharp the thing was that went through him. It wasn't jealousy. It was relief, so big it hurt.

Richard stood beside them, silent, holding one of Julian's hands in both of his.

"Jules," Theo called.

Julian looked up. Over Annie's shoulder his eyes found Theo's. He looked about a hundred years old.

"Go home," said Theo. "Sleep. I'll sort the rest."

"Theo. Please. Don't do anything stupid."

"Me?" He pressed a hand to his chest. "I'm a professional coward."

That got the ghost of a smile.

They went out slowly, the three of them, in a knot, Annie's arm through Julian's, Richard a step behind. Dana had come out of the office to see them off. She caught Richard's sleeve at the glass doors, and Theo, standing three yards away with a paper cup he'd forgotten to drink, heard her say, very low:

"We're going back out to the godown first thing Monday. The Harlow place. Brandt wants a drill on every wall in that building. We should have the warrant tonight."

Richard nodded. He didn't say anything. His face did something small and hard, and then he reached out and patted Dana's arm, once, and they went out through the doors into the thin grey afternoon.

Theo stood in the corridor.

Every wall.

Lime, said something in his head. Ten bags. Twelve. For the Harlow job.

He put the cup down.

He didn't decide it. There was no moment. He was simply walking, out through the glass doors and down the steps and across the car park, while Julian's white van pulled away from the kerb with Annie driving and Richard's old saloon turned the other way. He got into his own car. He sat with the keys in his hand and the engine off.

Monday is two days away. Whoever it is has two days.

He thought of Julian in a plastic chair. Julian shaking in the rain.

I'm not going to open it, he promised himself. I'm going to look. That's all. I'll look at a wall, go home, and feel like an idiot.

He started the car.

He texted at the first red light, engine ticking, because it seemed important to leave a thread behind him.

Theo: Jules. I think I've found something. Harlow godown. Going there now.

Theo: Bring the big hammer and a torch when you can. The plasterer's one. Don't call Dana. I need to be SURE first.

Theo: I think I can clear you.

And then, to a different name, his thumb hesitating on the glass:

Theo: Annie. I'm about to do something stupid. Not dangerous. Just stupid. Back soon. I know you’ll be mad about this so I have my apology ready.

Theo: Also, I meant it. About the note. Every word.

He looked at that for a second. Then he added, because he couldn't help it, because he had never in his life been able to leave a feeling alone without putting a joke on top:

Theo: The pirate was optional.

The light went green. He put the phone face down on the seat, and drove.

*

He reached the location and looked around. As brave as he sounded in his head, he wasn’t. He took a piece of paper from the dashboard and scribbled something on it before taking a deep breath and stepping out.

The sliding door stood open a hand's width. Someone had cut the chain and never replaced it.

He stood in the thin afternoon with a crowbar from the boot in one hand, pushed the door, and went in.

The light inside was grey and slanting, falling in long dusty bars through the broken skylight. The air smelled of rust and damp and very old stone. His footsteps rang on the concrete, flat and hollow, and the sound went up into the rafters and came back to him changed.

It's just a building, he told himself. It's just a big empty building with pigeons.

He crossed the floor with the crowbar against his chest, past the fallen sheets of tin, past a rusted pallet, past a long stain on the concrete that he walked round without knowing why. Along the side, an iron staircase climbed to nothing in particular, and he ignored it. The wall was what he'd come for.

It ran across the back of the building, long and grey and streaked with damp, from one corner to the other. It looked as old as the rest. It looked as though it had stood there a hundred years.

He walked its length slowly, hand outstretched, brushing the brick with his fingertips. It was cold, and gritty, and wet. He stopped in the middle. He looked at the lower courses, where the damp had left a dark, uneven band. He crouched and looked closer.

Rust had been rubbed into the bricks. Not stained, not weathered. Rubbed. In long, careful, deliberate strokes, as if with a rag.

And the mortar between them, when he scraped at it with his thumbnail, came away in pale, gritty flakes, far too clean under the grime.

Lime, he thought. Ten bags. Twelve. Eight. Pays in singles.

His mouth had gone dry.

He stood, set the point of the crowbar against the mortar line at knee height, and leaned.

It didn't want to give. He worked at it, grunting, sweating in the cold, the metal slipping and shrieking in the quiet. His hands began to ache. The noise was awful, loud as a bell in the dark, and every few seconds he stopped, held his breath, and listened for footsteps.

Nothing came.

The light faded as he worked. He lost track of how long. A flake of mortar fell. Then a bigger piece. Then, with a dry, grinding crunch, one brick shifted in its bed and slid half an inch outward.

He knelt, got his fingers round it, and slowly drew it out.

It was heavier than he'd expected. He set it on the floor beside him, very gently, as if it might break. A cold breath came out of the dark where it had been. A smell. Faint at first, and then not faint at all.

He didn't want to look.

He took out his phone, switched on the little torch, and held it to the hole.

There was a space behind the wall. A narrow, deep cavity as long as the wall itself, blacker than the building around it. The beam slid in, trembled, and found a surface. A fold of cloth. A wrist.

A hand.

Theo made a small sound and sat down hard on the concrete.

He didn't scream. He wasn't sure he had the breath. He sat with his back against the cold wall, knees drawn up, the phone light shaking in his hand, and thought, in a small and distant way, Oh. It's real.

It's real.

It's all real.

He thought of Gordon Pryce, squinting at a camera, refusing to smile. A woman called Marianne he'd never met. A caretaker with a library card. A man behind a counter who remembered how his sister took her tea. All of them in the dark, one after another, a long patient row of people in this cold and silent place, while the town kept looking the wrong way and Julian sat in a cell with his hands shaking.

I knew, he thought. I knew it wasn't him.

It should have felt like triumph. It felt like nothing. It felt like falling.

He got the phone up again. He had to call someone. Dana. He had to call someone now, and his thumb was moving to the screen, and the signal was thin and flickering, and he'd got as far as the first digit of her number when he heard it.

Far off, at the end of the long dark building, a sliding door groaned along its track.

He went completely still.

The windows had turned the colour of ash. He'd been working for hours. A bar of fading light swung across the floor, and two shadows moved in it. Slowly, unevenly, side by side. Footsteps on concrete. One light and quick, one heavy, an older man's tread, stopping and starting.

And a voice, very tired, very gentle, very familiar, a voice Theo would have known anywhere.

"I don't understand," said Richard. "Why here?"

Theo's heart stopped.

He killed the phone light. He rose into a crouch in the dark, the brick still at his feet, the crowbar in his hand, his breath held tight in his chest. Beyond the fallen sheets, the footsteps came on.

Richard.

The name turned over, cold, in his mind.

Richard knows this place. Richard's been here before. Richard goes quiet every time the old case comes up. He closed it in nine days, and he's been first through every door since. He's been in this town forty years, and he knows where everything is, and...

No.

Don't be stupid. He's seventy. He's grey. He can barely manage stairs. He held a spoon like it weighed a stone.

But the doubt wouldn't leave. It sat in him, small and cold, in the dark, with the smell of the wall in his nose, and for three long breaths he couldn't tell whether the man walking toward him across the floor was the one who needed saving, or the one who'd done this.

Another voice answered, from beside him. A quiet, careful, hoarse voice, one Theo couldn't place.

"Because I wanted to show you. I've waited a long time. You'll see."

Theo pressed himself against the cold bricks, and didn't move, and didn't breathe.

Somewhere, in his pocket, his phone buzzed once, softly, with Annie's name.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.