The Cost Of Silence

Ch. 12 · 12. Birthday

Chapter 12

12. Birthday

12 min read

"Absolutely not," said Theo. "No balloons."

"It's a birthday."

"It's a surprise birthday. Balloons announce that something's happening. Balloons are a confession."

Julian glanced up from the list in his hand with the patient face of a man who had been listening to this for forty minutes. They were in the kitchen at Richard's, the table covered in paper plates, a ball of string, and a cake recipe Theo had printed out and instantly regretted.

"Annie doesn't like surprises," Julian said. "She likes plans. If she walks in and finds a plan, she'll be happy."

"She'll be suspicious."

"She'll be happy and suspicious."

"That's a very specific emotion."

"It's Annie."

Richard sat at the end of the table with a pencil behind his ear, doing the crossword and pretending not to listen. He'd looked thinner for a week now, and the hand holding the paper wasn't quite steady. But the planning had done him good. Every so often a small private smile crossed his face, as though the noise in his kitchen were a kind of medicine.

"Eight o'clock," Richard said, without looking up. "Dinner. I'll do the roast. Julian does the potatoes, because I can't be trusted with potatoes."

"You boiled a potato into soup once."

"It was an experiment."

"And Theo," said Julian, "will do the cake."

Theo clutched his chest. "Me?"

"You printed a recipe."

"I printed it as a joke. I printed it the way you'd print a map of a country you're never going to visit."

Julian gave him a look. It wasn't unkind. It was tired, and a little thin at the edges, and Theo realised, with a small cold jolt, that he hadn't properly looked at Julian in days. There were shadows under his eyes. There was a grey smear of something on his shirt cuff. He'd been leaving for work at dawn and coming home after dark, and when Theo had asked about it, he'd just said, "Busy season," and changed the subject.

"I'll buy a cake," Theo said.

"Fine."

"A good one. From the place on Pine. With her name on it in icing, so she knows it's a real, committed cake."

"Fine."

"And a present." Theo's voice dropped. "I've got a present."

Julian's eyebrows went up. "You have?"

"It's secret. Very secret. It's even a secret from me."

"What does that mean?"

"No idea, but I said it with confidence."

Richard made a small noise that might have been a laugh, and bent lower over his crossword. Julian shook his head and went back to the list, and Theo watched him for a moment, the sharp, tired profile in the lamplight.

"You alright?" he said, more quietly.

"I'm fine."

"You look like you haven't slept."

"I'm fine, Theo."

It came out sharper than he'd meant. They both heard it. The kitchen went still. Julian put down his pen and rubbed his eyes with the heel of his hand, and when he looked up again, the old easy warmth was back in his face, though it seemed to take some effort, like a man pulling on a coat in the cold.

"Sorry," he said. "That was rude. It's work. There's a job I can't finish, and the client keeps changing his mind." He tried a smile. "I'll sleep after the party. Promise."

"You'd better."

"I will."

"That wasn't a promise. That was a hostage negotiation."

Julian laughed, and the tension drained out of the room. But later, alone on the porch with a mug of tea, Theo found himself thinking about the grey smear on the cuff. And then he made himself stop. Julian had plaster on his clothes the way other people had lint. It meant nothing. It was just Julian.

*

The call came on Wednesday, and by half eleven Theo was sitting in the passenger seat of Julian's van, eating a stale pastry and trying to look as if he wasn't terrified.

"I'm not coming in," he said. "I'll wait out here."

"You're coming in," said Julian. "You've been sitting in my van for forty minutes."

"It's a very nice van."

"It smells of wet cement."

"That's why I like it. It's honest."

They'd been summoned by Richard, who had rung at breakfast sounding grey and hurried. He'd left his blood pressure tablets on the kitchen counter, and he wanted them at the station, now, before a four o'clock meeting. Julian was the only one with a vehicle. Theo had offered to tag along, because it beat staying at the shop pretending to understand dishwashers.

The station was as dreary inside as it had been last time. Strip lights, bad coffee, a wall of notices nobody read. A tired-looking desk sergeant waved them through with a bored flick of the wrist, and they walked down the long corridor past the interview rooms, their footsteps loud on the lino.

At the far end, on a bench against the wall, sat a thin, weather-beaten man in layered coats, knees pressed together, a carrier bag at his feet.

Theo had seen him round town. Everyone had. The man who slept behind the tyre shop, who sometimes stood outside the bakery at closing time waiting for whatever the owner couldn't sell. Eddie, people called him. He had a gentle, anxious face, and hands that never seemed to know where to settle.

He glanced up as they came near, then quickly down again.

"Morning," Theo said, because it seemed rude not to.

"Morning," Eddie murmured. He didn't meet his eyes. His gaze moved briefly to Julian, and rested there a moment too long. Then he dropped it and started studying his own hands as if they held some answer.

He's scared, Theo thought. Poor bloke. They've probably had him here for hours.

Julian slowed beside the bench. For a second Theo thought he might say something. But the door of the nearest interview room opened, and Dana stepped out with a folder under her arm, followed by Richard, looking worse than he had that morning.

"There you are," Richard said. "Thank you. You're lifesavers."

"You look terrible," said Julian, handing over the tablets.

"I'm perfectly well."

"You're grey."

"I'm distinguished." Richard shook out two pills, swallowed them dry, and rubbed a hand over his face. "Dana's doing the second round with the boy. Cal. And with him." A tilt of the head toward the bench. "Just a few follow-ups. We won't be long."

"We can wait," Theo said. "I've got a very full schedule of nothing."

Dana went over to the bench. "Mr Finch? Eddie? We'd like another word, when you're ready."

Eddie got up at once, as though he'd been waiting his whole life for permission, gathered his carrier bag, and followed her into the second interview room with his head down. "Edward Finch," Theo heard her tell the officer at the door, who wrote it on a clipboard. "Witness. Follow-up." Then the door closed behind them with a soft click, and Richard went in after them.

Theo and Julian stood in the corridor, awkwardly, in the glare of the lights. Theo was watching Julian, who had gone very still, one hand on the strap of his bag, staring at the door.

"You okay?" Theo whispered.

"Fine."

"That's your word of the week."

"Don't."

The door of the first room opened, and a uniformed officer stepped out with a clipboard, followed by Chief Brandt himself, looking, Theo thought, extremely pleased about something.

"Mr Reyes will be coming with me," Brandt said, in the bland, careful voice of a man making an announcement he'd rehearsed. "Cal Reyes. We have some questions about the disappearance of Mr Pryce. I'd like him to come downstairs."

Behind him, in the open doorway, Cal stood with his hands half raised, white-faced, saying, "I didn't do anything, I didn't, I swear I didn't."

"No one's accusing you," Brandt said, in the same flat voice, as they took him by the arms.

Dana had come out of the second room behind him, her mouth a thin line. She didn't speak. But as the officers led Cal away down the corridor, her eyes went past Theo, past Julian, to the end of the hall, where a window looked onto the car park. In the car park, parked crookedly under a lamp, stood a white van with a ladder on the roof.

She looked at it for a long moment.

Then she looked at Julian.

"Mr Wright," she said. It was the first time Theo had ever heard anyone call him that. "Have you got a minute?"

"Of course."

"It's nothing. Just routine." Her voice was light, and her eyes were not. "Do you buy your supplies from Dunmore's? Dunmore Builders' Supply, on the east side?"

Julian blinked. "Yes. For most of my work. Why?"

"A man who worked there, Ernie Fallon, hasn't been seen for two weeks. His sister reported him missing on Monday." Dana tilted her head. "I'm just talking to his regulars. Seeing if anyone noticed anything. Did you know him?"

"A bit. He was the one on the counter." Julian's voice was perfectly steady. "He remembered everyone. Called me by name."

"When did you last see him?"

"I can't remember. A few weeks ago." A pause. "I'm sorry. I should have realised sooner. That's awful."

"It's alright." Dana smiled. "I'll be in touch."

She turned and walked back to the interview room. Julian stood watching her go, and Theo, beside him, felt the old cold feeling settle over his skin again, the one he'd had on the bridge.

"She doesn't think you..." he began, and laughed, because it was so absurd. "Jules. She doesn't actually think..."

"No," said Julian. "Of course not."

But he didn't look at Theo when he said it.

They walked back down the corridor in silence, past the notices nobody read, and out into the thin grey light of the car park. The van's engine took two goes to start. Julian sat for a moment with both hands on the wheel, staring through the windscreen at nothing, before he put it in gear.

*

By the time Annie's birthday came round, the town had decided Cal Reyes was guilty.

Theo didn't believe it. Not for a second. He'd watched the boy being led down that corridor with his face the colour of paper, and he'd thought, with total clarity: That is a person who has never hurt anything in his life. But the papers had printed his photo, and the neighbours had started whispering, and on the Thursday of the party, someone had spray-painted a word across the front of his mother's house.

"It's wrong," Theo said, for the third time that evening. "Everyone's got it wrong."

"You said that already," said Julian.

"It's still true."

"I know."

They were laying the table at Richard's, lamps turned low, the good napkins out, and a tablecloth that smelled faintly of mothballs. Richard was in the kitchen, swearing at a roast. The cake from the place on Pine sat on the sideboard under a tea towel, with HAPPY BIRTHDAY ANNIE in blue icing and, in smaller letters underneath, (WE'RE SORRY), which had been Theo's idea.

The doorbell went at eight on the dot.

"Places!" Theo hissed. "Everyone! Look surprised! Look, Richard, look surprised, don't just stand there with a spoon!"

"I am surprised. I'm always surprised when you ring a doorbell."

Annie came in wearing a green dress and her good coat, hair loose, cheeks flushed from the cold. She stopped in the hall and took in the room. The lamps, the long table, the flowers Julian had put in a jug, the cake on the sideboard. Her eyes moved from one face to the next.

"You didn't," she said.

"We absolutely did," said Theo.

"I told you I didn't want..."

"Happy birthday," said Julian, quietly. He was standing by the table in a clean shirt, looking tired and handsome and slightly nervous. "We don't have to do anything. We just wanted you to know."

She looked at him, and her face did something soft and complicated. "Thank you."

"Anytime."

"It's so much."

"It's a roast and some potatoes," said Richard. "Calm down."

The evening unfolded the way the best evenings do, without anyone noticing. The roast was almost edible. The potatoes were excellent. Theo gave a toast that went on far too long, and Richard told a story about Annie's first night at the house, when she'd stood in the hall for ten minutes pretending to look at the photos, and nobody laughed, and everybody smiled. Annie wiped her eyes and said she was fine, she was fine, it was only the candles.

When the plates had been cleared, Theo cleared his throat and fetched a small wrapped parcel from under the sideboard.

"I've got a present," he said. "It's not a great present. It's a present with potential."

Annie unwrapped it slowly, the paper tearing under her fingers. Inside, in a nest of tissue, was a mug.

It was a plain white mug, slightly lopsided, with a handle set a touch too high. On the side, in wobbly blue paint, someone had written two letters with a plus sign between them: T + A. The A was a bit backwards, and the T had a drip.

"I made it myself," said Theo. "At one of those pottery places. Took three hours. They asked me to leave twice."

Annie held it in both hands. She didn't say anything. She looked at the mug, then at him, and her mouth trembled.

"It's lopsided," she said, in a small, wobbly voice.

"It's artisan."

"The A's backwards."

"It's a stylistic choice." He smiled. "Now you've got three mugs, which is two more than anyone needs. But I felt you should have the option."

She laughed, and the laugh broke into something else, and she hugged the mug to her chest with both arms and shook her head.

"Don't," she said. "I'll cry all over the cake."

"The cake can take it."

At the end of the table, Julian said nothing. He sat with his hands folded, looking at the mug, at the crooked blue letters, at the girl holding it. His face stayed very still. Then he stood, and said, in an even voice, that he'd put the kettle on.

Annie caught Theo's eye across the table. Is he okay?

I don't know, Theo's face said.

Later, when everyone was warm and slow and full of cake, Annie got up to clear the last plates. She moved round the table with a stack in her hands, humming softly and without thinking, the way people do when they're happy. A handful of small notes, a little climb and a little fall.

She caught herself and laughed. "Sorry. I do that."

"Don't stop," said Theo.

A small, strange feeling brushed him as he said it. He knew that tune. He was nearly sure of it, with the faint prickle of a word on the tip of the tongue: he had heard it somewhere, not long ago, a few thin notes climbing and falling, and for a moment he very nearly had it. Then it slipped away.

The radio, he decided. Some shop, some bus. Everything went round and round on the radio these days.

"It's embarrassing," said Annie.

"It's nice," he insisted, and she smiled and carried on into the kitchen, and the tune faded behind her. He leaned back in his chair with his glass and listened to the clock ticking in the hall and Annie laughing with Richard over the washing up, and thought he had never in his life been so happy.

Through the kitchen door, Julian stood alone by the kettle, staring at nothing, and Theo, watching him over the rim of his glass, thought: Something's wrong with him.

And then, because it was a birthday, and he was happy, and because Julian had always been the one who looked after everyone else, he thought:

I'll ask him tomorrow.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.